Welcome to SpellCoder Sign in | Join | Help

Forums Sucks, Especially this one

This is hilariously funny situation
About a month ago I joined an Egyptian forum called Egypt-Developers, because I found a thread talking about .net vs java so I wanted to join the talking, and I really enjoyed the discussion, because the forum was full of java guys and most of them were not guru's so it was really easy discussion.
then after a while another thread started there which was a try to make a cleaner thread to learn both technologies together, so it was interesting, but I found some rules wrote by the Admin ,he is a Java guy by the way, which most of them are not even logical in a discussion.
these are the rules
  1. No judgment will be allowed, this thread objective is only learning not comparing.
  2. All provided information should be supported by reference and the technology should be released or at least in Beta version. Any Alpha or future feature may be discussed only after released.
  3. No discussion on the tools or IDEs unless in the context of providing the needed example of the feature under discussion.
  4. Any violation of this rule will result in deletion of your post and may be put your posts under moderation. Posts may be edited by the admin in order to be compliant with these rules.
  5. I will be the chairman who manages this thread so please all technical suggestion should be post in this thread and I will pick them then deleted them in order to clean the thread and make it focusing on the current topic.
So as you see
rule #1 is really funny, how can you start a thread talking about Java & .net and you ask people not to judge & compare.
rule #2, You can't mention a feature that it is in a alpha edition, which is not logical too, and this is a try to make the .net guys not to mentions features in C# 3.0 & VB9 & LINQ and lots of other future stuff in .net, which was really unfair
rule #3 Which means don't say the word Visual Studio in the comparison or you will be deleted
rule #4 The killing rule, if you don't obey my rules you will be vanished.
rule #5 Then the power rule, I am the GOD of this place so no one can say something that I don't like, I will delete every post until all people get out.

so if you are a .net developer you will be out of discussion in seconds, and that what happened, I was banned from posting in the forum after less than 24 hours when I wrote my objection about these rules...
So I decided to blog about it to see, which is stronger Blogs, or Forums
kick it on DotNetKicks.com
Digg It
Published Saturday, November 04, 2006 7:58 PM by Mohammed Hossam
Filed Under:

Comments

# re: Forums Sucks, Especially this one

Saturday, November 04, 2006 11:42 AM by Hussein
am with you that Blogs are hundred times better than forums, but it’s not the problem of the forums itself it's us who puts the rules i think we really have a problem in the Tech. Community in Egypt which is my word is always above all which is wrong, we don't accept any comparison or logical and reasonable talk, just wanted to share those words with you and good luck ISA

# re: Forums Sucks, Especially this one

Saturday, November 04, 2006 5:50 PM by Mostafa
This is not funny, this is depressing to be heard!
I faced a lot of personalities like this guy, who are the reason why we are still working in the IT the old way!

Which is, don't discuss, and obey!

# re: Forums Sucks, Especially this one

Saturday, November 04, 2006 6:23 PM by Dody Gunawinata
"
and PLEASE READ BEFORE REPLYING BECAUSE I HATE TO TALK WITH SOMEONE THAT DOESN'T CARE TO READ THE OTHERS OPINIONS"

http://www.egypt-developers.com/forum/forum/viewthread?thread=1137&offset=50

ha..ha..ha..

# re: Forums Sucks, Especially this one

Monday, November 06, 2006 3:59 AM by BlackWasp
I nearly replied to that last thread but took a deep breath instead.  It is better for your health.  :-)

# re: Forums Sucks, Especially this one

Monday, November 06, 2006 1:57 PM by I don't f-ikng care
if you don't like it you don't have to join. you are a whine bag

# re: Forums Sucks, Especially this one

Friday, November 10, 2006 8:46 PM by shay
the forum is ok but till now i dont understand what happened..i hate rules and i love to say my opinion freely without any threat, am not sure if am right or wrong in this matter but if am posting in a forum with rules i will not post, its difficult to choose the words which r not violating the rules sometimes:)
Anonymous comments are disabled